Tag Archives: water privatization

U.N.’s water agenda at risk of being hijacked by big business

By Thalif Deen, February 11, 2013.  Source: Inter Press Service

Amidst growing new threats of potential conflicts over fast-dwindling water resources in the world’s arid regions, the United Nations will commemorate 2013 as the International Year of Water Cooperation (IYWC).

But Maude Barlow, chairperson, Council of Canadians and a former senior advisor on water to the president of the U.N. General Assembly in 2008-2009, warns the U.N.’s water agenda is in danger of being hijacked by big business and water conglomerates.

“We don’t need the United Nations to promote private sector participation under the guise of greater ‘cooperation’ when these same companies force their way into communities and make huge profits from the basic right to water and sanitation,” Barlow told IPS.

At this time of scarcity and financial crisis, she said, “We need the United Nations to ensure that governments are fulfilling their obligations to provide basic services rather than relinquishing to transnational corporations.”

The Paris-based U.N. Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organisation (UNESCO), which has been designated the lead U.N. agency, formally launched IYWC at a ceremony in the French capital Monday.

In New York, Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon warned of the new pressures on water, including growing populations and climate change. One-third of the world’s 7.1 billion people already live in countries with moderate to high water stress, he said.

“Competition is growing between farmers and herders; industry and agriculture; town and country,” Ban said. Upstream and downstream, and across borders, “We need to cooperate for the benefit of all now and in the future… Let us harness the best technologies and share the best practices to get more crop per drop.”

Back in December 2010, the 193-member General Assembly adopted a resolution declaring 2013 as the IYWC, following a proposal by Tajikistan.

The 2013 World Water Day, which will take place on Mar. 22, will be dedicated to water cooperation.

Barlow told IPS big water corporations have gained influence in almost every agency working at the United Nations.

The CEO Water Mandate, a public-private sector initiative launched by the United Nations in July 2007 and designed to assist companies in the development, implementation and disclosure of water sustainability policies and practices, puts corporations such as Nestle, Coca Cola, Suez and Veolia directly into a position of influence over global water policy and presents a clear conflict of interest, she said.

“For-profit private companies cannot uphold the public interest if it conflicts with their bottom line,” said Barlow, who is also founder of the Blue Planet Project.

Even the World Water Development Report is now advised by an industry group on “business, trade, finance and involvement of the private sector,” she added.

Tom Slaymaker, senior policy analyst on governance at the London-based WaterAid, told IPS the United Nations recognised the “human right to water and sanitation” back in 2010.

“But today over 780 million lack improved water supplies and 2.5 billion lack basic sanitation facilities,” he added.

The 2013 International Year of Water Cooperation will be a critical year for the United Nations to reflect on why universal access has not yet been achieved, he said.

Slaymaker said it’s also time to reflect on the kind of political leadership and new forms of partnership that are required to accelerate progress towards universal access as part of the emerging post-2015 development framework of the United Nations.

According to the United Nations, the primary objective of IYWC is to raise awareness, both on the potential for increased cooperation, and on the challenges facing water management in light of the increase in demand for water access, allocation and services.

Since the General Assembly recognised the human right to water and sanitation, a number of countries, including Mexico, Kenya, Bolivia, The Dominican Republic, Rwanda, Ethiopia, Ecuador, El Salvador, The Netherlands, Belgium, the UK and France, have either adopted laws recognising the right to water or amended their constitutions to do so.

The Vatican recently recognised the human right to water and added that “water is not a commercial product but rather a common good that belongs to everyone.”

And last June, all 193 member states signed the Rio+20 Declaration which includes the recognition of the human right to water and sanitation as a universal right.

Specifically zeroing on the role of the private sector, Barlow told IPS that corporations are among those pledging their support for IYWC.

Aguas de Barcelona, the water company at the heart of a fierce debate in Spain over control of drinking water, is participating, she pointed out.

So are “corporations who fought us on the right to water are now scrambling to claim it in their own image”.

She quoted Nestle as saying that 1.5 percent of the world’s water should be put aside for the poor and rest should be put on the open market.

If Nestle gets its way, she argued, there will one day be a water cartel similar to big oil, making life and death decisions about who gets water and under what circumstances every day.

“But at least we have this recognised and acknowledged right that no one should be allowed to appropriate water for personal gain while others die from an inability to pay for water,” she said.

With time, “we will build consensus around the right to water and the understanding that water is a common heritage and a public trust.”

Leave a Comment

Filed under Corporate Globalization, Food Sovereignty, Industrial agriculture, Water

Members of the Global Water Justice Movement Refute Profit Maximization as Water Governance Model

“… some water justice activists in the audience put on red clown noses to drive the message that the World Water Forum is one big corporate fair.”

Special to Climate Connections by Levi Francisco, IBON International 

14 March 2012, MARSEILLE, France—On the second day of the World Water Forum, a water debate titled, “Private/Public Involvement in the Provision of Water and Sanitation Services,” was held at the Palais des Congres, Parc Chanot. The debate was moderated by Paul Barrett.

Arguing for the side of public services were Maria Theresa Nera-Lauron of IBON International who acts as coordinator of Water for the People Network and David Boys who is the Utilities Officer at Public Services International. Championing the arguments for privatization, on the other hand, were  are Gerard Payen, President of AQUAFED, the International Federation of Private Water Operators and Mamadou Dia who is Managing Director of Sénégalaise des Eaux.

Boys mainly pointed out how supporting public services in water and sanitation instead of resorting to privatization has given way to “low risks and high returns.” Such returns include health, family stability, and community coherence, which are among the many other socio-cultural aspects that cannot be taken into account within market mechanisms.

Lauron talked about the continuing ill-effects of the failed privatization experiment of Metro Manila’s water services, touted by the World Bank to be a ‘model’ of public-private partnerships. The Philippines, Lauron mentioned, now has the highest water rates in Asia, with an almost 1,000% increase in prices since the start of privatization. And worst, there are still more than 200 ‘waterless communities’ in Metro Manila, not serviced because the private contractors did not think they were ‘financially viable’.

Machines will save us. Photo: courtesy IBON

On the other side of the panel, Payen stated that the debate should not be about private participation versus public involvement but being able to guarantee the best solutions to deliver this service to the other 40% of the global population which are being served by neither. As the AQUAFED president was delivering his presentation, some water justice activists in the audience put on red clown noses to drive the message that the World Water Forum is one big corporate fair.

Diametrically opposite to the situation in Manila, Dia expounded on the case of Senegal, illustrating how partnership with the private sector has led to reforms in the water sector, promoting democratic participation and sustainability in his country.

The debate highlighted the inherent contradiction between private and public participation in the water sector. But beyond this, the more important issue is that of governance of water resource management. Water is common good that should not be governed by the logic of profit maximization that is best exemplified by private corporations.  Reclaiming public water and upholding the human right to water are the real solutions to the water crisis. This is the message of the Alternative World Water Forum that is taking place from March 14-16 at Docks des Suds.

1 Comment

Filed under Climate Change, Corporate Globalization, Water